ARTICLE | 6 MIN | VIEWS FROM THE FLOOR

Views From the Floor

September 29, 2020

Without Momentum, what next? Barra returns re-examined; the tailwind to Chinese bonds; and the super forecasts of the Superforecasters.

Quote of the Week:

"It’ll all be revealed, it’s going to come out. But after the audit."

Donald Trump dismisses a report by the New York Times – that he paid just USD750 a year in federal income taxes in 2016 and 2017 – as “made up” and “totally fake news”.

Frothing, Then Bubbling

On a Barra factor basis, it has been relatively easy to explain the selloff in the three weeks to 18September: momentum collapsed.

Inter-quintile returns showed that no other factor performed particularly well in response, meaning that there was no factor rotation to provide support – instead, the market went straight down (Figure 1).

But how does this move in the three weeks to 18 September compare with the rest of the year? More context is given by Barra factor performance year-to-date (Figure 2), with the blue bars illustrating the moves between the start of the year and 21 August, and the yellow bars illustrating the moves between 24 August and 18 September. There are three main themes to point out:

  • While Value has finally started working, this is miniscule compared with the negative trend seen earlier in the year;
  • Volatility, Liquidity (or Barra’s measure of excess turnover) and Speculative Risk – measure of speculation and frothiness in the market – have been positive this year;
  • None of the ‘fundamental’ measures, except for Growth, have performed well.

There are also regional disparities within factor performance (Figure 3):

  • Value has struggled in all regions, but has struggled the most in the US;
  • Momentum has performed well in all regions, especially in Europe and emerging markets;
  • The performance of Speculative Risk and Liquidity – measures of frothiness in markets – has been rewarded in the US relative to Europe, which has seen flat or negative returns, respectively, for both factors.

Figure 1. Barra Momentum Collapses in Three Weeks to 18 September

Barra Momentum Collapses in Three Weeks to 18 September

Source: Bloomberg, Man Numeric; between 24 August and 18 September 2020.

Figure 2. Performance of Barra Factors in 2020

Performance of Barra Factors in 2020

Source: Bloomberg, Man Numeric; between 24 August and 18 September 2020.

Figure 3. Performance of Barra Factors by Region

Performance of Barra Factors by Region

Source: Bloomberg, Man Numeric; as of 18 September 2020.

A Following Wind: Chinese Bonds and the FTSE Russell

Last week, index provider FTSE Russell announced the inclusion of Chinese bonds in its World Government Bond Index from 2021 at estimated 5.7%. This will almost certainly accelerate foreign inflows, which have been on a tear in 2020 (Figure 4).

By our estimates, the value of the stock of foreign owned Chinese government and agency bonds is less than 1% of the market cap of the Bloomberg Barclays Global Aggregate for treasuries and agencies. As a share of the total stock of Chinese bonds, it’s around 8%. In contrast, in many other emerging markets, the figure regularly exceeds 20% (Figure 5).

Figure 4. Foreign Ownership of Chinese Treasury and Agency Bonds

Foreign Ownership of Chinese Treasury and Agency Bonds

Source: Man Group, Bloomberg, Chinabond; as of 24 September 2020.

Figure 5. Foreign Ownership of Chinese Treasury and Agency Bonds

Foreign Ownership of Chinese Treasury and Agency Bonds

Source: Man Group, Bloomberg, Chinabond; as of 24 September 2020.

A combination of factors – incoming flows, a booming export sector which has taken market share in most major markets during the COVID-19 crisis, and widening spreads between Chinese government bonds and the US – are a reasonable backdrop for a stronger Chinese yuan over the medium term, in our view. This, in turn, could create a tailwind for Asia versus the rest of the world. Figure 6 shows the very tight inverse relationship between a stronger yuan and Asia ex-Japan’s relative performance versus the MSCI World over recent years.

Figure 6. CNY – Asia ex-Japan Versus MSCI World

CNY – Asia ex-Japan Versus MSCI World

Source: Bloomberg; as of 24 September 2020.

There should be one other material attraction for allocators as Chinese markets continue to open up. In a recent article, we illustrated the potential diversification benefits of allocating to China. And indeed, with 10-year government bonds yielding 3%, and a firmly negative correlation between stocks and bonds, China stands out as a particularly promising destination for risk parity strategies.

Figure 7. Two-Year Rolling Stock/Bond Correlation by Region

Two-Year Rolling Stock/Bond Correlation by Region

Source: Man Group, MSCI, Bloomberg; as of 24 September 2020.

Superforecaster's Super Forecasters

Two weeks ago, we observed a sharp decline in the Good Judgement Project’s (‘GJP’) Superforecaster survey of expectations regarding the timing of Covid-19 vaccine availability. The percentage of superforecasters anticipating distribution of 25 million doses of an FDA-approved vaccine in the US between 1 October, 2020 and 31 March, 2021 declined from a high of 71% on 8 September to 54% as of 23 September.

At the time, firms exposed to an extension of the pandemic – those in Goldman Sachs’s Health Risk Basket (namely airlines, casinos, hotels and cruises) – had not underperformed despite this renewed pessimism. However, it seems like the market has caught up with the Superforecasters – with the basket falling around five percentage points on 21 September – highlighting the slowness with which a theoretically efficient market sometimes reacts. In contrast, it bolsters the view that there if there is one thing better than the wisdom of the crowds, it is the wisdom of well-informed crowds – and that forecasting is vastly more successful in a probabilistic framework.

Figure 8. GJP Superforecasters Covid-19 Vaccine Predictions

GJP Superforecasters Covid-19 Vaccine Predictions

Source: The Good Judgement Project; as of 28 September 2020.

Figure 9. Goldman Sachs Health Risk Basket

Goldman Sachs Health Risk Basket

Source: The Good Judgement Project; as of 28 September 2020.

The Trials and Tribulations of Factor Correlations

Just a few weeks ago, we discussed how a factor-tracking index might have several unintentional secondary exposures – and how Momentum and Growth were perhaps the true culprits behind a Value index’s torrid 2020. We’ve explored this idea further, looking into the correlations between these two factors. While some factor correlations may be structural – such as Growth and Value’s historically negative correlation – investors should note when these begin to reach unusual depths or heights. In our review of the data, we found that the 2-year rolling correlations of Momentum and Growth are unusually elevated. Conversely, Momentum and Beta correlations are notably negative.

This is significant for investors seeking meaningful diversification in their factor exposure. A higher Momentum stock is now more likely than normal to be a Growth or a low-beta stock at the same time. While many factors are typically correlated within themselves, unusual correlation situations such as this make it more difficult for investors to gain a full picture of the characteristics of a stock and ensure their portfolio has the necessary diversification.

Figure 10. Momentum Versus Growth Correlation (2-year Rolling)

Momentum Versus Growth Correlation (2-year Rolling)

Source: Man Numeric, as of 11 September 2020.

Figure 11. Momentum versus Beta Correlation (Two-year Rolling)

Momentum versus Beta Correlation (Two-year Rolling)

Source: Man Numeric, as of 11 September 2020.

With contributions from: Jay Rajamony (Man Numeric - Head of Alternatives), Ed Cole (Man GLG - Managing Director – Equities), and Ikitsa Anastasov (Man GLG - Deputy Head Portfolio Manager).

For further clarification on the terms which appear here, please visit our Glossary page.

This information is communicated and/or distributed by the relevant Man entity identified below (collectively the "Company") subject to the following conditions and restriction in their respective jurisdictions.

Opinions expressed are those of the author and may not be shared by all personnel of Man Group plc (‘Man’). These opinions are subject to change without notice, are for information purposes only and do not constitute an offer or invitation to make an investment in any financial instrument or in any product to which the Company and/or its affiliates provides investment advisory or any other financial services. Any organisations, financial instrument or products described in this material are mentioned for reference purposes only which should not be considered a recommendation for their purchase or sale. Neither the Company nor the authors shall be liable to any person for any action taken on the basis of the information provided. Some statements contained in this material concerning goals, strategies, outlook or other non-historical matters may be forward-looking statements and are based on current indicators and expectations. These forward-looking statements speak only as of the date on which they are made, and the Company undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in the statements. The Company and/or its affiliates may or may not have a position in any financial instrument mentioned and may or may not be actively trading in any such securities. Unless stated otherwise all information is provided by the Company. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Unless stated otherwise this information is communicated by the relevant entity listed below.

Australia: To the extent this material is distributed in Australia it is communicated by Man Investments Australia Limited ABN 47 002 747 480 AFSL 240581, which is regulated by the Australian Securities & Investments Commission ('ASIC'). This information has been prepared without taking into account anyone’s objectives, financial situation or needs.

Austria/Germany/Liechtenstein: To the extent this material is distributed in Austria, Germany and/or Liechtenstein it is communicated by Man (Europe) AG, which is authorised and regulated by the Liechtenstein Financial Market Authority (FMA). Man (Europe) AG is registered in the Principality of Liechtenstein no. FL-0002.420.371-2. Man (Europe) AG is an associated participant in the investor compensation scheme, which is operated by the Deposit Guarantee and Investor Compensation Foundation PCC (FL-0002.039.614-1) and corresponds with EU law. Further information is available on the Foundation's website under www.eas-liechtenstein.li.

European Economic Area: Unless indicated otherwise this material is communicated in the European Economic Area by Man Asset Management (Ireland) Limited (‘MAMIL’) which is registered in Ireland under company number 250493 and has its registered office at 70 Sir John Rogerson's Quay, Grand Canal Dock, Dublin 2, Ireland. MAMIL is authorised and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland under number C22513.

Hong Kong SAR: To the extent this material is distributed in Hong Kong SAR, this material is communicated by Man Investments (Hong Kong) Limited and has not been reviewed by the Securities and Futures Commission in Hong Kong.

Japan: To the extent this material is distributed in Japan it is communicated by Man Group Japan Limited, Financial Instruments Business Operator, Director of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (Financial instruments firms) No. 624 for the purpose of providing information on investment strategies, investment services, etc. provided by Man Group, and is not a disclosure document based on laws and regulations. This material can only be communicated only to professional investors (i.e. specific investors or institutional investors as defined under Financial Instruments Exchange Law) who may have sufficient knowledge and experience of related risks.

Switzerland: To the extent this material is made available in Switzerland the communicating entity is:

  • For Clients (as such term is defined in the Swiss Financial Services Act): Man Investments (CH) AG, Huobstrasse 3, 8808 Pfäffikon SZ, Switzerland. Man Investment (CH) AG is regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (‘FINMA’); and
  • For Financial Service Providers (as defined in Art. 3 d. of FINSA, which are not Clients): Man Investments AG, Huobstrasse 3, 8808 Pfäffikon SZ, Switzerland, which is regulated by FINMA.

United Kingdom: Unless indicated otherwise this material is communicated in the United Kingdom by Man Solutions Limited ('MSL') which is a private limited company registered in England and Wales under number 3385362. MSL is authorised and regulated by the UK Financial Conduct Authority (the 'FCA') under number 185637 and has its registered office at Riverbank House, 2 Swan Lane, London, EC4R 3AD, United Kingdom.

United States: To the extent this material is distributed in the United States, it is communicated and distributed by Man Investments, Inc. (‘Man Investments’). Man Investments is registered as a broker-dealer with the SEC and is a member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (‘FINRA’). Man Investments is also a member of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (‘SIPC’). Man Investments is a wholly owned subsidiary of Man Group plc. The registration and memberships described above in no way imply a certain level of skill or expertise or that the SEC, FINRA or the SIPC have endorsed Man Investments. Man Investments Inc, 1345 Avenue of the Americas, 21st Floor, New York, NY 10105.

This material is proprietary information and may not be reproduced or otherwise disseminated in whole or in part without prior written consent. Any data services and information available from public sources used in the creation of this material are believed to be reliable. However accuracy is not warranted or guaranteed. © Man 2025