Whenever AI stocks stumble, investors ask the same question: how do we diversify away from crowded, expensive technology winners without sacrificing returns? Typically, the answer is to rotate out of "growth" and into traditional "value" sectors such as banks.
In Japan, which has had one of the world’s strongest equity markets over the past three years, that standard playbook now appears to be upside down. The contrarian opportunity has shifted away from the crowded financial sector and toward physical AI hardware suppliers, heavy-asset industrials that are much less exposed to AI disruption, and tariff-hit automakers.
Value and contrarian are not always the same thing
That is because investors often treat "value" (buying cheap stocks) and "contrarian" (buying what is unpopular) as the same strategy, and pair "growth" with "momentum" in the same way. Yes, most of the time they overlap, since a cheap stock is typically out of favour and a growing company usually enjoys strong price momentum. But the best opportunities can appear when those pairs split apart. And both of those shifts appear to be underway in Tokyo right now.
For the past five years, Japan’s big banks have been a textbook example of a cheap value trade that turned into momentum. After decades of deflation and sub-zero interest rates, inflation finally returned after the pandemic and the Bank of Japan began raising interest rates. Higher borrowing costs allowed banks to charge more for loans, lifting their profits.
Back in 2021, Japan’s mega-banks were deeply unloved, trading at just half the value of the net assets on their balance sheets (0.5 times book value). As interest rates rose, investors piled in, turning a contrarian value play into a crowded momentum trade. Today, those same banks trade at nearly twice their book value and make up more than 40% of Japan’s top-cap value index.
Figure 1: Higher interest rates lifted Japanese banks out of deep value
Source: Bloomberg, as at 29 Oct 2026. Chart shows price to book ratio of the TOPIX Banks Index against the yield on the 10-year Japanese government bond.
Problems loading this infographic? - Please click here
With Japanese interest rates now approaching more normal levels at around 1.5%, the easy gains from that re-rating appear to be behind us. Investors hiding in financials to escape technology volatility may also be overlooking the risk that banking is one of the more obvious white-collar industries that AI could eventually disrupt.
Bargain multiples in Japan's AI "picks and shovels"
While banks have grown expensive, repeated bouts of technology selling since July have done the opposite to Japan’s AI supply chain. Unlike Silicon Valley, Japan does not have giant software companies building large language models. Instead, Japanese firms make the physical "picks and shovels" needed to build and power data centres globally, including optical fibre cables, power equipment, specialist semiconductors and flash memory chips.
At the height of the AI rally in late June, these hardware companies accounted for roughly 18% of Japan’s benchmark TOPIX Index; during the November pullback, their weight dropped closer to 11.5%, Bloomberg data shows. When the first wave of selling hit in July, buying the dip was still a growth bet rather than a classic value play, as valuations had not yet fallen to traditionally cheap levels. By November, however, indiscriminate selling pushed several profitable hardware suppliers down to multiples normally associated with deep value.
At the recent troughs, leading makers of optical cabling and automotive chips traded at between 10 and 14 times expected earnings, while memory chip makers, down up to 70% from their June peaks despite strong cash generation, compressed to 2.5 times this year's consensus earnings and 1.7 times next year's, according to Bloomberg data. Even if profits at those memory companies were to fall by three-quarters next year, they would still sit on single-digit earnings multiples.
We don’t need to know exactly what AI will look like in 2030, or how leadership changes at US chipmakers will play out, to see the asymmetry in those numbers. Market anxieties often centre on the risk that US tech giants may slow the pace of their data-centre spending. Yet a more measured rollout could prove healthier, stretching out the hardware cycle and giving AI revenues time to catch up with capital investment.
Hedging both sides of the AI trade
Because it is hard to know whether the AI trade will enjoy another major leg higher or unwind further, pairing cheap hardware suppliers with neglected "old economy" value could help mitigate risks in either scenario. Outside the mega-banks, much of Japan's industrial and mid-cap value sector has lagged since the pandemic, held back by investor anxieties over global manufacturing and Chinese growth.
That caution has left two areas looking particularly mispriced. The first is "HALO" businesses, meaning heavy assets with low obsolescence, such as steelmakers, shipping lines and mining equipment firms. If the AI buildout continues, upgrading power grids and building data centres will require vast quantities of copper, steel and energy equipment. If it falters, these asset-heavy businesses trade on low multiples and are highly unlikely to be disrupted by software.
The second is Japan’s automotive sector. US tariff fears have pushed export-driven carmakers to valuations that make them arguably the deepest value area left in Japan, assigning almost no worth to their core businesses once cash and cross-shareholdings are stripped out.
Yet pricing these companies solely as tariff-hit carmakers ignores a broader industrial skillset. Having spent decades developing humanoid and assembly-line machines, with one leading manufacturer planning to deploy 400,000 robots across its factories next year, Japan's automakers own factory-automation capabilities that extend well beyond building cars.
Parting thoughts
Value as a broad style has had a strong five-year run in Japan, and history suggests the next five years are unlikely to be quite so straightforward now that the bank recovery is well advanced.
Yet in a market dominated by fast money and momentum, greed and fear tend to stretch further in both directions, removing valuation caps on the way up and valuation floors on the way down. For investors willing to look past traditional style boxes, that volatility is creating opportunities across the spectrum, from overlooked steel and industrial companies to profitable AI hardware names where fear appears to have temporarily taken over.
All data Bloomberg, unless otherwise stated.
Author: Nick Wilcox, Managing Director, Discretionary Equities, Man Group.
You are now leaving Man Group’s website
You are leaving Man Group’s website and entering a third-party website that is not controlled, maintained, or monitored by Man Group. Man Group is not responsible for the content or availability of the third-party website. By leaving Man Group’s website, you will be subject to the third-party website’s terms, policies and/or notices, including those related to privacy and security, as applicable.